Atlanta Short-Term Rental Net Yield Drops to 3.3% After Costs

The gross short-term rental premium in Atlanta (Fulton County) runs at 89% for a 3-bed house, but after Airbnb fees, insurance, maintenance, utilities and property tax, that gap compresses substantially. This article covers both a 3-bed house and a 2-bed apartment because the cost structures differ materially: apartments carry lower entry prices but add HOA fees that houses never pay.

All figures below assume self-management for both short-term rental and long-term rental, matching the dashboard defaults. A section later in the article shows what hiring a professional manager does to net yield.

The 3-Bed House: Gross Revenue of $44,521 Shrinks to $16,331 Net

A median 3-bed house in Fulton County sells for around $497,915 and grosses $44,521 on the short-term rental market at a market occupancy of 50%. Long-term, the same property rents for $1,966/month, or $21,779 annualized. The table below shows what each strategy leaves on the table after all costs.

The Airbnb rate of 15.5% applies to Airbnb specifically. Other platforms charge differently: Vrbo sits closer to 5% and Booking.com around 15%, so a multi-platform strategy can shift total fee drag by a few thousand dollars a year.

Airbnb Fees and Utilities Eat the House Premium

The largest single cost absent from the long-term rental column is the $6,901 in Airbnb fees, which alone erases roughly a third of the gross revenue gap. Utilities add another chunk: short-term rental operators pay the full $2,832 because guests never see the bill, whereas long-term tenants typically cover utilities themselves, leaving only a fraction on the landlord.

Maintenance is the second structural gap. Short-term rental maintenance at $7,577 includes furnishing replacement, deep cleans between turnovers and faster wear on fixtures, while long-term maintenance of $4,855 reflects routine repairs only. Insurance also runs higher for short-term rental at $4,985 versus $3,485 for a standard landlord policy, because commercial-style short-term coverage prices in guest liability.

The 2-Bed Apartment: Lower Entry Price, HOA Drag

A 2-bed apartment in Fulton County sells for around $126,018, a dramatic drop from the $497,915 house entry price (the apartment median reflects all Fulton County condo and apartment stock, including older inland units; modern intown high-rises trade well above this median). The apartment grosses $26,351 on the short-term rental market, or $19,377 annualized as a long-term let. The table below includes the HOA row, which applies regardless of rental strategy.

HOA fees of $2,297 sit in both columns because the building charges them whether the unit is let nightly or annually. This is the structural disadvantage of condos and apartments that single-family houses avoid entirely.

Apartments Win on Net Yield Despite HOA

The 2-bed apartment posts a short-term rental net yield of 8.0% against the 3-bed house's 3.3%. On the long-term rental side, the apartment delivers 10.9% versus 1.9% for the house. The apartment wins decisively on percentage yield in both modes, primarily because its much lower entry price of $126,018 (versus $497,915 for the house) compresses the denominator faster than HOA fees of $2,297 per year add to the cost stack.

That said, absolute dollar income tells a different story. The house generates $16,331 of short-term rental net income against the apartment's $10,036, so an investor with the capital to buy the house outright takes home more cash even though the percentage return is lower. The apartment wins on yield and capital efficiency; the house wins on absolute cash income. The right answer depends on whether the investor is optimising for return-on-capital (apartment) or total dollar return (house).

Short-Term Rental Breaks Even at 27% Occupancy

For the 3-bed house, the gross break-even occupancy is 27%, meaning short-term rental gross revenue equals long-term rental annual rent at that fill rate. This is a floor, not a target: the market median occupancy in Fulton County sits at 50%, well above the break-even. An underperforming listing that cannot clear 27% would earn less gross than simply letting the property long-term, before the extra short-term costs are even counted.

View Atlanta in the dashboard → Free preview · every bedroom count and property type

Professional Management Drops House Net Yield to 1.3%

The tables above assume self-management, which is the dashboard default. Hiring a short-term rental manager for the 3-bed house adds around $9,795 per year, roughly 22% of gross revenue, pushing total costs to $37,984 and dropping net yield from 3.3% to approximately 1.3%. That fee covers guest communication, cleaning coordination, pricing optimization and compliance, which for an out-of-state investor is often worth the margin hit.

On the long-term side, a letting agent typically charges around 9% of rent collected, adding roughly $2,123 per year and compressing long-term net yield to about 1.4%. Because long-term management is a smaller percentage of a smaller revenue base, the dollar impact is lower than short-term management, but the proportional yield hit is still meaningful for thin-margin long-term rentals.

Tax Treatment: Depreciation and Schedule E Absorb the Sting

Georgia has a state income tax, so investors do not benefit from the state-tax exemption that Florida or Tennessee owners enjoy. However, federal tax treatment still helps significantly. A 3-bed house at $497,915 carries a depreciable building value of approximately $398,332 (80% of sale price), generating around $14,485 per year in depreciation deductions over the 27.5-year residential schedule. For most investors, that deduction can shelter much of the operating income from federal tax in the early years, though the actual benefit depends on income level, financing structure, and whether passive-activity loss rules apply.

Both short-term and long-term rental income flow through Schedule E (or Schedule C for very active short-term operators providing hotel-like services). Mortgage interest, repairs, property tax and insurance are deductible above the line. The dashboard calculates after-tax cashflow for each scenario. Permit required ($150) in Atlanta. Atlanta requires short-term rentals permits and annual registration. No night cap. Properties must meet safety requirements and maintain liability insurance. Hotel and motel taxes apply.

Atlanta in National Context

The Fulton County gross long-term rental yield of 4.7% sits below the national median of 5.3%, though the short-term rental gross yield of 8.9% is materially above typical long-term yields in most US markets. Entry prices in Fulton of $497,915 run well above the national median 3-bed house price of $242,500, reflecting Atlanta's status as the Southeast's largest metro.

Suburb-level variation is substantial: top-yielding zones include Union City (30291) at 8.9% gross long-term yield and Atlanta (30310) at 8.4%, while premium areas in north Fulton price well above the county median. These are county medians; individual suburbs diverge significantly. The dashboard shows suburb-level data for every bedroom count and property type, so an investor can filter to the specific ZIP they are considering.

Data reflects market conditions as of April 2026. For a full methodology on how these figures are constructed, see the data sources and market score methodology. Explore rental data in the dashboard for neighborhood-level figures. Atlanta Short-Term Rentals Nearly Double Long-Term Rental Yields covers the gross-yield gap in the same market, and Georgia Rental Investment Insights digs into property-type selection in more detail.

This information is for educational purposes only and should not be considered financial or legal advice. Regulations and market conditions change frequently. Verify current rules with local authorities before making investment decisions.